---
description: Our free tool can help you get a quick and detailed side-by-side comparison for Payroll Mate vs PrimePay. Learn more about each of these software and make the best decision for your business.
image: https://gdm-localsites-assets-gfprod.imgix.net/images/getapp/og_logo-94fd2a03a6c7a0e54fc0c9e21a1c0ce9.png
title: Payroll Mate vs PrimePay Comparison | GetApp New Zealand 2026
---

Breadcrumb: [Home](/) > [Payroll Software](/directory/259/payroll/software) > [Payroll Mate \<span\>vs\</span\> PrimePay](https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay)

# Compare Payroll Mate vs PrimePay

Canonical: https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay

> Detailed comparison between Payroll Mate and PrimePay. Check ratings, reviews, pricing, and features to make the best decision for your business.

-----

## At a Glance

| Metric | Payroll Mate | PrimePay |
| **Overall rating** | 4.6/5 | 4.0/5 |
| **Total Reviews** | 131 | 381 |
| **Starting Price** | US$219.00 | - |
| **Free Trial** | Yes | No |
| **Free Version** | No | No |
| **Deployment** | Windows (Desktop), Windows (On-Premise), Linux (On-Premise) | Cloud, SaaS, Web-based, Mac (Desktop), Windows (Desktop), Linux (Desktop), Chromebook (Desktop) |
| **Support** | Email/Help Desk, Phone Support, Chat | Email/Help Desk, FAQs/Forum, Knowledge Base, Phone Support, Chat |
| **Training** | Documentation | Live Online, Webinars, Documentation, Videos |

## Key features

### Payroll Mate

- 401(k) Tracking
- API
- Accounting
- Benefits Management
- Check Printing
- Direct Deposit
- Employee Portal
- Multi-State
- Payroll Management
- Payroll Reporting
- Tax Compliance
- Vacation/Leave Tracking
- W-2 Preparation
- Wage Garnishment

### PrimePay

- 401(k) Tracking
- API
- Accounting
- Applicant Tracking
- Benefits Management
- Biometric Recognition
- Check Printing
- Customisable Templates
- Direct Deposit
- Employee Portal
- Multi-State
- Payroll Management
- Payroll Reporting
- Performance Management
- Recruitment Management
- Reminders
- Tax Compliance
- Vacation/Leave Tracking
- W-2 Preparation
- Wage Garnishment

## Links

- [View Payroll Mate Profile](https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/20528/payroll-mate)
- [View PrimePay Profile](https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/2064318/primepay)
- [View Original Comparison](https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay)

-----

## Structured Data

<script type="application/ld+json">
  {"@context":"https://schema.org","@graph":[{"name":"Payroll Mate vs PrimePay Comparison | GetApp New Zealand 2026","description":"Our free tool can help you get a quick and detailed side-by-side comparison for Payroll Mate vs PrimePay. Learn more about each of these software and make the best decision for your business.","url":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay","about":[{"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/20528/payroll-mate#software"},{"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/2064318/primepay#software"}],"breadcrumb":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay#breadcrumblist"},"@type":["WebPage","CollectionPage"],"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay#webpage","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/#organization"},"isPartOf":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/#website"},"inLanguage":"en-NZ"},{"name":"Payroll Mate","description":"Comprehensive payroll software that fits the needs of accountants, small and medium size businesses. Payroll Mate automatically calculates net pay, federal withholding tax, Social Security tax, Medicare, state and local payroll taxes. Payroll Mate also supports different types of payroll pay periods, prints checks, prepares payroll forms 941, 944, 940, W2 and W3. Payroll Mate software also supports user-defined income, tax, and deduction categories, making it very flexible and powerful with the ability to add on options like direct deposit capability, generate W2 forms on blank paper, and MICR checks. Payroll Mate can also generate forms California DE-6, California DE-7, Texas C-3, Texas C-4, New York NYS-45, Illinois IL-941 and Illinois UI-3/40. Payroll Mate exports payroll data to QuickBooks, Quicken and other accounting software like Microsoft Office Accounting.","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/e4bb24dc-e843-412a-84d1-3929fdbe1b2e.jpg","url":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/20528/payroll-mate","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/20528/payroll-mate#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","ratingValue":4.6,"bestRating":5,"ratingCount":131},"offers":{"price":"219","@type":"Offer","priceCurrency":"USD"},"operatingSystem":"Windows, Windows on premise, Linux on premise"},{"name":"PrimePay","description":"PrimePay makes payroll and HR complexity disappear. We've packaged 37 years of experience and an unrelenting commitment to service into an intelligent, versatile HCM platform for people-centric businesses. More than 16,000 clients — including Aspirion, Solution Group, Stagnaro Bros. Seafood, SERVPRO of Anniston, and Nova Care Agency — rely on the PrimePay HCM Platform to replace manual work, replace compliance worries, and stop wasting time on things that should just work, so they can get back to work. \n\nWant to know more about our technology?\n•\tIt just fits. PrimePay is HR and payroll on your terms – a plug and play solution that gives you options, so you can quickly start with basic payroll or HR and add time tracking or benefits when you need them.\n•\tIt just works. PrimePay is an HR and payroll solution that does what it should do – what you and every employee expect. Checks are right, taxes are taken care of, and benefits are clear. And the entire process is fast and simple for HR.\n•\tWe’re all in. PrimePay takes service seriously, and we’ve proven it for decades. So you’ve got a guide to help you through all the challenges and changes that come with managing HR and payroll.\n\nTo learn more, visit primepay.com.","image":"https://gdm-catalog-fmapi-prod.imgix.net/ProductScreenshot/43e033ae-6e0f-459d-8979-313380a6f5a3.png","url":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/2064318/primepay","@type":"SoftwareApplication","@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/software/2064318/primepay#software","applicationCategory":"BusinessApplication","publisher":{"@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/#organization"},"aggregateRating":{"@type":"AggregateRating","ratingValue":4.0,"bestRating":5,"ratingCount":381},"operatingSystem":"Cloud, Apple, Windows, Linux, Chrome"},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","@id":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay#breadcrumblist","itemListElement":[{"name":"Home","position":1,"item":"/","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Payroll Software","position":2,"item":"/directory/259/payroll/software","@type":"ListItem"},{"name":"Payroll Mate vs PrimePay","position":3,"item":"https://www.getapp.co.nz/compare/20528/2064318/payroll-mate/vs/primepay","@type":"ListItem"}]}]}
</script>